Street Address – Identifier – Circa Date
East Alex-Bell Road
595 -- Peter Sunderland -- 1820 d, e
650 -- Aaron Nutt Jr. -- 1833 d, e + stone smoke house
2447 -- Thomas Horner -- 1820 d
West Alex-Bell Road
1855 -- David Lamme -- 1840
Austin Road
1580 – Munger/Willis – 1860 a, d
Bigger Road
7325 – Blair/Weller -- 1813 d + 2 stone outbuildings
Centerville Station Road
1262 -- School House #2 – 1846
2200 – Unknown – 1880 a
2230 -- William Reeder -- 1806
Clyo Road
7520 – Wilson/Weller -- 1842 e (Now 1200 Forrest Walk)
8110 -- John Tate -- 1825
8981 -- David Miller -- 1826
9739 -- Aaron Robbins -- 1813 a, b
East Franklin Street
25 -- James Harris -- 1838 d
47 -- E. Davis -- 1895 a
52 – McGrath -- 1899 a
59 -- Jacob McCracken -- 1833
West Franklin Street
4 -- Clark Pine Store -- 1810
18 -- C.W. Haines -- 1870
21 -- K of P Lodge -- 1890 a
27 -- Henry Reeder -- 1830
27(a) -- Jos. Fisk Cottage -- 1810 d Behind 27
33 -- D. Woods -- 1895
39 -- Joseph Vorhees -- 1827
63 -- Nathanial Strong -- 1835
74 -- James Manuel -- 1875
79 -- Robert McEwen -- 1833 d
89 – Reese/Walton -- 1840 d
101 -- 1st High School -- 1885
116 – Chambers -- 1865 a
150 – Will Frazee – 1890 a
Glencroft Drive
80 -- Lawson Allen, MD -- 1838 d
Hewett Road
2000 – James White/Abraham Prugh -- 1840
Hibberd Drive
138 – John Carmony/Jesse Kelsey -- 1848
Irongate Drive
15 – John Beck/Frank Harris -- 1820 d
Lebanon Pike
8661 -- John Archer -- 1839 d, e
9950 -- Jonathon Watkins -- 1804 c
10273 -- Samuel Broadaway -- 1815 Owned by Township
Mad River Road
5683 -- School House #9 -- 1875
5835 -- Samuel Yike -- 1834
6004 -- Elizibeth Popenoe -- 1888
6058 -- Isaac Harrison -- 1809
6320 -- Levin Hatfield -- 1820 c
6581 – Edwin Smith/Elisha Hopkins -- 1803
6720 -- 2nd Edwin Smith -- 1820
7235 -- Unknown -- 1825
North Main Street
3 -- James Harris Store -- 1838
26 -- Asahel Wright -- 1806 d
30 -- William Buckles -- 1830 a
38 -- 1st Baptist Church -- 1871
52 -- T. Watkins -- 1895 a
60 -- Andrew Vincent -- 1832 d
78 -- Aaron Nutt -- 1818 d
81 -- Benjamin Robbins -- 1809 d
84 – Weller -- 1895 a
94 -- Joseph Beck -- 1837 d
166 – Benham/Gerber -- 1885
232 -- School House #5 -- 1874
South Main Street
18 -- Old Centerville Library -- 1895 a, d
22 -- B. W. Himes -- 1885 a
23 -- Elisha Jones -- 1820 d
39 -- Phoebe Hatfield -- 1882 a
43 – Benham -- 1879 a
89 -- Daniel Newport -- 1835 d
Maple Avenue
10 -- Zenos Hines -- 1839 a
23 -- Joseph Tice -- 1814 d
29 -- James McKinney -- 1835d
West Miamisburg-Centerville Road
2025 -- John Belville -- 1835
Newell Circle
5301 -- John Bigger Jr. -- 1850
Nutt Road
575 -- John Hatfield -- 1835 d
West Rahn Road
1050 -- John Prugh -- 1835
East Ridgeway Drive
32 -- Clarence Nutt -- 1890 a, b
Sheehan Road
10370 – Garard/Hatfield -- 1860
East Social Row Road
1243 -- John Harris -- 1809
1284 -- Robert Bradford -- 1839 b, c
1286 -- Job Jennings -- 1833 b
1351 -- Israel Harris -- 1809
West Spring Valley Road
444 – Unknown -- 1855 a
1164 -- Noah Tibbals -- 1810
Stone Lake Drive
5690 -- Moses Irvin -- 1830
Sugar Creek Point
8820 – Watkins/Sears -- 1826 d
Weller Avenue
25 -- Lot 20 N. Main St. -- ???? Moved c. 1950
59 -- Lot 20 N. Main St. -- ???? Moved c. 1907
Wellesley Way
361 -- John Hole -- 1820 a, d Waterwheel Building
East Whipp Road
520 – J. Pompenoe Jr. – 1851a
West Whipp Road
281 -- John Ewing -- 1800
485 -- H. R. Gilbert -- 1845
519 -- Woodbourne Inn -- 1818
530 -- Willliam Whitnell -- 1825
610 -- Townley Tavern -- 1825
Wilmington Pike
5285 -- James McCracken -- 1857 e
6239 -- Ebenezer Andrew -- 1835 e
7155 – Opdyke/Williamson -- 1815 e
Yankee Street
6900 -- Peter Whitman -- 1820
7380 -- Jacob Musselman -- 1860
8701 -- Daniel Garrison -- 1839
9480 -- Noah Tibbals -- 1825
9505 -- Asher Tibbals -- 1815 e
9679 -- Milton Munger -- 1829 e (Now 9731 Tibbals Ct.)
9955 -- Edmund Munger -- 1826 Owned by Centerville
Properties, not noted otherwise, are in the CWH publication, ”A Sense of Place.”
a Not listed in “A Sense of Place”
b Landmarks Foundation Marker
c On the National Register of Historic Places
d In the Ohio Historic Inventory
e A Centerville Landmark property (Unified Development Ordinance, Sec. 7.25)
If you find any mistakes or are aware of any nineteenth structures we’ve missed, let us know.
This list was generated by the Landmarks Foundation in 2000.
Edited and amended by Jerry Strange in October 2024.